Showing posts with label 1960s. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 1960s. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 20, 2011

Pasolini's Jesus, Matthew's Words

Pasolini’s The Gospel of Saint Matthew presents Pasolini’s Jesus with Matthew’s words. An antiesht, gay, Marxist making a Jesus film, especially in the 1960’s, is certainly a novelty – Pasolini’s film does not disappoint. While the text is taken and restricted to the Gospel of Matthew, the on screen presentation is what makes Pasolini’s vision unique. It is not just that Jesus takes on an activist, Marxist persona, but we find a dramatically human Jesus in a visually striking landscape.
Praise
The Biblical epics of the 1960’s tended to place Jesus in sweeping vistas with dramatic views. Pasolini’s presentation is equally striking, though for different reasons. The harsh Italian landscape with its dilapidated villas creates a sense of foreignness, antiquity, struggle, and poverty. The scenery induces a deep sense of pain and trouble inherent in the lives of the common people. Certainly this is in line with Pasolini’s Marxist ideology, but the film is no cheap ploy or propaganda piece. One is invited into the suffering and scarcity of the characters on the scene in a a particularly organic way. The cinematography invites the viewer to see Jesus in a new light. If this film and its agenda had been filmed by a director of less skill it would have become intolerable to watch. Pasolinin is able to present a controversial understanding of Jesus in a very acceptable way by using only the Biblical text as dialogue and scenery/other chapters to really push the agenda inherent in the movie.
This film also affords an intimate look at many characters. Close up shots and long silences from the lack of dialogue allows Pasolini to invite the viewr into the lives of the characters. The opening scene has a well done close up of Mary with cuts to the adolescent Joseph. The emotion and passion is unmistakable. The Biblical account does not give Joseph’s initial reaction to Mary’s pregnant state. Pasolini cannot have a dialogue in this case, so he uses good acting and cinematography to tell the story. So often mediocre film relies on dialogue and effects to drive the plot. Pasolini’s film is remarkable because it uses the understatement of black and white film and the skill of his actors and crew to move the plot. This is even more remarkable considering that none of the actors are professionals. This film is note worry simply from these technical aspects of filmmaking.
Pasolini also adeptly navigates the tension between a human and divine Jesus. Pasolini does not shy away from showing miracles, though they happen in abrupt and disjointed ways. The teachings of Jesus are also central to the film, namely the Sermon on the Mount. The divine Jesus of the virgin birth and miracles is shown alongside the mortal, moral teacher. Few other Jesus films where crafted in such a way as to preserve such a tension. Pasolini is likely able to maintain this dual identity by adhering closely to the Gospel account.
Critique
The Marxist influence and agenda of the movie, while not abrasive, is rather idiosyncratic. While the cinematography and visual action on the scene is enthralling, it is occasionally disjointed from traditional understandings of the life of Jesus. The Sermon on the Mount is traditionally viewed as a teaching on how to be a good moral agent. Pasolini's presentation makes it into a sort of 'call to arms' in which a social transformation is central. The Sermon on the Mount becomes more about social activism and societal reform than it does about how to live one's life before God. Much of the film could be collapsed into this sort of understanding. By the end of the film the viewer comes away with an idea of how to be a good citizen in the world, but not necessarily how to be a faithful person before God.
The historicity of Jesus is also uniquely challenged in this film. Pasolini is much more concerned about the impact of Jesus than about the Jesus of history. While using the Biblical text, Pasolini's visuals re-write the Jesus story in profound ways. Jesus amongst the poor masses and the influence this had is more important than the complex and confusing character seemingly portrayed in the Gospel. Pasolini's Jesus is a Jesus without ambiguity. The viewer knows who Jesus is and what Jesus is about, its only the disciples that seem to misunderstand Jesus' social message. This stands as a weakness in Pasolini's presentation because part of the power of the Jesus narrative is its ambiguity. This ambiguity and indistinctness of Jesus' activity in history could lend itself to a very deep plot. What we receive on the screen, is rather superficial in that there is little development to who Jesus is or what Jesus is about.

Friday, March 18, 2011

Jesus the Revolutionary

The Italian filmmaker Pier Paolo Pasolini seemed on the surface an unlikely suspect to make a Jesus film. Marxist, atheist, and openly gay, at the time Pasolini decided to make a film based on the Book of Matthew, he was considered a controversial and even dangerous filmmaker by Italian authorities.

Enrique Irazoqui as Jesus, 1964
Yet this 1964 film, The Gospel According to St. Matthew (Il Vangelo Secondo Matteo), is often cited as one of the most beloved films about Jesus by believers and non-believers alike. Without question the 1960s Jesus film that is most faithful to scripture, nearly all of its dialogue comes straight from the New Testament. When other films dress up their dramatic moments through bombastic score or saccharine lighting, this film is understated, simple, reverent. 

Miracles happen with no fanfare at all; they simply happen, so quickly that it is startling and effective. Likely because Pasolini was limiting himself to dialogue included in scripture, there are often long stretches of onscreen silence, which play beautifully.

My favorite use of silence is in the exquisite opening scene. An anguished Joseph stares at an unhappy and mute teenaged Mary in a grotto, trying to fathom how she could betray him. He finally stumbles away from her house and, in confusion, falls asleep, his brow furrowed. The first audible dialogue of the entire film is that of the angel appearing to him.

The film has a distinct Marxian sympathy for the poor, and much screen time is devoted to the quiet faces of those everyday people who encounter Jesus in his ministry. Even the most unlikely characters -- the uneasy soldiers sent by Herod to massacre the innocent male children of Bethlehem, for example -- are shot by Pasolini with compassion and tenderness. Children and the elderly are in nearly every scene. This, Pasolini wants to emphasize, is the story of the poor, and of Jesus's dedication to them.  Most of Pasolini's actors were nonprofessionals; many were laborers themselves. His own elderly mother plays the role of Jesus's mother as an older woman.

Pasolini's Jesus (played by a Spanish graduate student, Enrique Irazoqui) is unflinchingly passionate, angry, and insistent upon justice. We see stories from scripture rarely enacted in other Jesus films. Pasolini includes the cinematically-unloved cursing of the fig tree, for example. In strident tones, Jesus also announces he comes not in peace, but to bring a sword -- a controversial line from scripture that bucks against the interpretation of Jesus as a placid peacemaker in films like King of Kings. 


Jesus also appears to turn his back on his saintly mother and family, a scene derived from scripture (Matthew 12:46-50) to which Pasolini gives particular emphasis. For American Christian audiences, a Jesus who doesn't seem to care much about his own family probably raises hackles. But it might provoke interesting questions about the way biological families are depicted in scripture. 

Margherita Caruso as Mary at sixteen
And indeed, for church discussion groups or academic classrooms, this film presents many fascinating questions. As a film with a decidedly Marxist agenda, what are we to make of its relative fidelity to scripture? Does it distort scripture? Or does it remind us of aspects of scripture American Christians often conveniently ignore? It can be fun to watch the film with the New Testament open, to see where changes in emphasis and order have arisen.

There is also the matter of the film's cryptic dedication to Pope John XXIII, which has been interpreted as tongue-in-cheek, sincerely reverent, or a nose-thumbing to Pasolini's Communist friends, many of whom argued Jesus was a sell-out subject for a supposedly revolutionary filmmaker.

The film is in Italian, although available with English subtitles, and it is in black and white, shot in a neorealist, documentary style. Of special note is its musical score, which includes Bach, the "Gloria" from a Congolese Mass, and Odetta's "Sometimes I Feel Like A Motherless Child."

All in all, this is a highly, highly recommended film -- in fact, an absolute must -- for anyone seriously interested in films or retellings of the life of Jesus.

Tuesday, March 1, 2011

Great Story, Boring Movie

The title of this film says it all. George Stevens intended his 1965 epic The Greatest Story Ever Told to be as majestic as its subject matter. Accordingly, every aspect of its production was taken to the extreme. The enterprise cost $20 million – more than any other film made in the U.S. to that point – with extensive pre-production, a star-studded cast, massive sets, and meticulous editing. Stevens wanted everything to be perfect, the greatest telling of the greatest story. His ambitious title also suggests an intention to tell a story with universal significance, in an increasingly pluralistic world. Yet, in spite of all the hype, The Greatest Story was a box-office flop, recovering only 17% of its production costs. Although contemporary reviews were mixed, later critics have generally seen it as a failure of Titanic proportions, which warned future filmmakers to steer clear of biblical epics. I will first examine what the film attempted, then consider why it failed.
“The Light Shines in the Darkness”
Stevens draws heavily from the Gospel of John. The film opens with a painting in a cathedral, accompanied by the beloved prologue: “In the beginning was the Word...” We see a dark screen, and gradually a light appears - first the star of Bethlehem, then a candle in the stable. Lest we miss the obvious, the narrator continues, “The light shines in the darkness, but the darkness grasped it not.” Greatest Story follows this “light” through his ministry, emphasizing Jesus' teachings and his spirituality. Likewise, we see the division between those “in the light,” who recognize Jesus as the Christ, and those “in the dark,” who do not “grasp” Jesus' true identity. The lighting in this film is very strategic. Jesus is always lit, while his opponents appear in the dark. Jesus and the receptive crowds (whom John the Baptist calls “decent sinners”) are clothed in shades of white, while his opponents wear dark colors. Often Von Sydow appears to be the source of light, as at the Last Supper, where the disciples on either side are lit from different directions, centering on Jesus, and a backlit window provides a halo effect.
Stern et. al. rightly note that Stevens's primary interest is the “Christ of faith,” rather than the “Jesus of history.” Perhaps this Jesus film, which premiered only four years after the very successful (and very historical) King of Kings, is partly a reaction against the excesses of the “quest for the historical Jesus.” Though in general the film attempts historical accuracy, there are obvious exceptions. Most strikingly, it is set not in Palestine, but in the American southwest! Beyond aesthetics, the decision to transplant the Jesus story suggests that its significance lies not in historical particularity but in a universal ideal.
“Seeing,” “Knowing,” and Defamiliarization
The film closes as it began, with a painting of the exalted Christ in a cathedral. This framing device (though cheesy) conveys a significant message about the film's purpose: Stevens defamiliarizes Jesus, challenging us to rethink the “great story” we thought we knew. Stern's claim that “no change has taken place from beginning to end” (143-144) is true only in terms of the film's narrative. The “change” Stevens intends is within the audience (“the kingdom of God is within you”).
Toward this end, Stevens employs the related Johannine tropes of “seeing” and “knowing.” “Old Aram,” who illustrates two different kinds of sight – physical and spiritual - comes from John 9. Stevens adds ambiguity about the precise moment Aram can see – is it in Nazareth or at Bethany? The latter seems more likely; the resurrection of Lazarus “opens his eyes” to Jesus' identity. Aram's testimony - "I was blind and now I see!” - receives an emphatic place, as the “last word” of the first half of the film. Similarly, “knowing” does not equal perceiving. The people of Nazareth fail to understand Jesus because they think they know him (c. Jn. 6:42; 1:12). At Jesus' trial, Caiaphas responds to Aram, “We know where he comes from!” This exchange evokes John 9 (c. 6:42; 7:27-29; 8:14). Only those who are in the light know Jesus. For those who reject the truth, “The light shines in the darkness, and the darkness grasped it not” (Jn. 1:5, quoted in opening scene).
The film's portrayal of miracles reflects the same idea - seeing (physical sight) is not believing (spiritual insight). On the two occasions when unbelievers demand a miracle, Jesus refuses (Nazareth and Herod's palace). Stevens similarly denies the audience direct sight of the miraculous. We see only four miracles (crippled man, bleeding woman, Aram, Lazarus), yet we hardly see even these. Most intriguing is the portrayal of Lazarus's resurrection; at no point does the audience see Lazarus! We must accept the testimony of witnesses. Likewise, even the resurrection of Jesus is not directly portrayed. Nor are there angels at the tomb, but only the “young man” of Mark's account. Nevertheless, all of the faithful believe immediately, even though they have not seen the resurrected Christ (c. Jn. 20:8). We cannot help but recall John 20:29: “Blessed are those who have not seen and yet have believed.” The message would not have been lost on Stevens's (intended) audience.
Christology
I suggest that the ultimate failure of Stevens's film arises from its christology. By exacerbating the gnostic tendencies in John, Stevens has given us an Apollinarian Jesus, who has a human body but not a human mind. His bourgeois European accent separates him from those around him, and his measured, sonorous voice seems more Sinai than Nazareth. The camera often points up at him, and we frequently see him elevated above the crowds (as, for example, at the Sermon on the Mount and the triumphal entry). James the Younger (Anderson) introduces a little refreshing levity, but his attempts to engage Jesus on a human level utterly fail. Similar exchanges with Peter, Matthew, and Martha fall flat, because Von Sydow's Jesus is more like an embodied doctrine (“Word”) than a human being.
He is also repellingly sanctimonious. His central message - “don't judge,” “don't worry,” “love one another” - contrasts with a holier-than-thou teacher who demands what humans cannot give. He judges Lazarus unworthy to be a disciple, because he will not give up everything he has and adopt Jesus' ascetic lifestyle. Lazarus looks to his sisters, who rely on him for support, and replies dejectedly, “What man can do that?” Then the holy posse leaves, and we see them walking by the sea barefooted, free of worldly obligations. Jesus' stoic disregard for external troubles seems at odds with his love commandment. While Jesus is teaching his little circle under a bridge, we see Roman soldiers passing overhead. The inside-outside dichotomy also works against Stevens; this Jesus seems to inhabit an ideal realm, separate from the “real world” within the stone confines of city buildings. Von Sydow preaches an impossible (and probably irresponsible) quietism.
If this Jesus is not very human, is he divine? Not necessarily. The question of Jesus-as-God versus Jesus-as-universal-ideal is left open, a prudent choice for the increasingly diverse theological climate of the 1960s. The quotation of John 12 (“unless a grain of wheat...”) suggests that the importance of Christ's passion is that it inspires an enduring movement. Significantly, we do not see the resurrected Christ until the ascension; a viewer may understand the resurrection literally, symbolically, or both. The important thing is the “Christ of faith,” the idea of Christ, not the historical person Jesus of Nazareth. Unfortunately for Stevens, an idea makes a boring protagonist!
What (Else) Went Wrong?
It seems that Stevens tries too hard to make his story the “greatest;” the excess squelches the film's merits. The epic is simply too long, with painfully slow pacing. Slow dialogue, long pauses, gradual fade-in transitions, and very traditional camera pans provide no relief from hours of Von Sydow's tedious messiahship. Stevens's over-the-top attempt at reverence sometimes backfires. Glaring examples are the “Hallelujah Chorus” and Jesus' Monty Python-esque ascent into the clouds.
Another failure-by-excess is the high-profile cast, which the original audiences found distracting. Nearly every important star in 1960s Hollywood makes an appearance, sometimes in only a brief cameo. The worst blunder of the entire film is John Wayne's drawling, “Surely, this man was the Son of God!”
Finally, this film had the misfortune of premiering at precisely the wrong time. Stevens appealed to the same traditional Christian audience which had flocked to the two King of Kings features (1927 and 1961). By the mid-sixties, the religious climate had changed. Almost contemporaneously with Greatest Story's premier, the cover of Time featured Altizer and the “death of God.” Postmodern Americans were growing weary of traditional religion, and suspicious of meta-narratives. “The Greatest Story Ever Told” proclaims “meta-narrative” in neon lights.
“The Medium is the Message"
If we examine this film according the Marshall McCluhan's famous insight, we may find another reason for its failure. For one thing, this is the first of our class films based on a novel; perhaps what translates to slow pacing on the silver screen would have captivated our imaginations between lines of print. More fundamentally, “medium” and (intended) “message” contradict one another. The film's central metaphor involves perspective; those in the light see Jesus for who he really is, while those in the dark cannot. The difference is not physical sight but spiritual insight. The message is faith, but the medium is spectacle. Stevens has tried to make the Christ of faith relevant by arraying him in worldly splendor. Instead, the effect is a parodic contradiction, like Herod's scarlet cloak.

Friday, February 25, 2011

Society, Politics, Justice and Evil in Nicholas Ray’s King of Kings

Nicholas Ray’s King of Kings (1961) is a firm depiction of the Biblical epic genre of film. It is also very much a product of the times in which it was made. Kings of Kings employed the cultural criticism, academic and technological advancements, and the emergence of youth culture to give an updated retelling of Cecile DeMille’s The King of Kings (1927). Right down to the title, Ray’s film invokes its forerunner, but is a significant deviation from it as well. Unique and pivotal to King of Kings is its historical-political focus, its concern for the subjective person, and a dramatically human portrayal of Jesus. Ray creates a Jesus of justice, morality, and love, though one that his contemporary’s and maybe even we do not understand. The historical nature and emphasis to the movie is the most dramatic and clear feature of the film. As such it is also the realm of most interest and importance in looking at this film. I will conclude with a few questions and some implications of Ray’s depiction of Jesus for theologies of justice.
History, Politics, Jesus, and The 60’s
King of Kings opens with a dramatic and sweeping image of the Roman occupation of Palestine. Red clad soldiers (a symbol of power throughout the movie) march in endless lines towards Jerusalem and the Temple located there. This is odd because it depicts events many years before the time of Jesus. For a Jesus film, the director has chosen to start quite a bit back from the beginning of his life. Fast-forward towards the time of Jesus and a similar scene depicts Pontius Pilate, later to figure prominently in the execution of Jesus, coming to Jerusalem. While on the way he is attacked by a band of Jewish rebels led by Barabbas. Ray, in these two scenes, has set the tone of the entire movie. There is a Jewish struggle for release from oppressive rule.
World War II has come to a close and by the sixties there is a rising consciousness of the Holocaust. The images of mass graves, burning bodies, and the tyrannical murder of the Jewish people is coming to the fore in post-war studies. The opening scenes of King of Kings clearly reflect this consciousness and concern. From images of mass graves to lines of Romans marching curiously similar to Nazi parades, Ray connects the social struggle of the ancient Jews to the present day political climate.
The sixties saw a major concern for political activism, cultural criticism, and historical evaluation. Biblical scholarship had been focusing on the history and culture of locale Palestine. This made possible many advances in understanding the dress, customs, and larger historical context in which the Biblical narrative is situated. Political activism and cultural criticism are also becoming mainstream at this time. Youth are questioning the roles, stereotypes, values, ideals, and motivations of older generations. The culture is one of great hope for change, firmly believing that one person can change the course of history.
Ray capitalizes on these trends in his opening scenes. The Gospel accounts are artistically placed in their historical context. The dress and equipment represented the best understandings of what the Roman legions actually carried. The costumes of the characters attempted to accurately reflect the clothing worn in the time period. Ray also focused the story on the politically charged nature of the times. The Gospel of Luke is the most important gospel to King of Kings because it has the most concern for narrative history. The movie may be said to be more of a presentation of first century Palestine, than a movie about Jesus.
Barabbas is introduced in the opening scenes, while we wait a good length of time for Jesus to arrive. The figures of Jesus and Barabbas are immediately juxtaposed. Both are seeking a dramatic change; Barabbas a change in social order through violent revolution and Jesus a spiritual revolution through peace. Barabbas’ peace and liberty comes only at the end of a sword and the beginning of self-rule free of the Romans. Jesus’ peace is an internal peace, the kingdom of God within, arrived at by the good moral life. As Jesus preaches in the Temple to gathered crowds, Barabbas stands outside leading a violent hoard through the streets. At the end of the movie Jesus is, of course, put to death and Barabbas is released. The resurrection is, though, a grand reversal, a demonstration that the way of peace and moral transformation is unconquerable, even by violent means.
The struggles of an emerging youth culture of political activism are firmly influential on Ray’s interpretation and presentation of the Jesus story. The miracles and divinity of Jesus is down played, or at least eclipsed by the moral teach and peaceful revolutionary of the human Jesus. The only extended scene featuring Jesus is the Sermon on the Mount. This is the pivotal ethical call of Jesus’ ministry and to Ray it is the ministry of Jesus. Ray also directed Rebel Without A Cause, which is also a peace of social commentary. Jesus is the rebel with a cause, the renewed spiritual vitality of a people. His power lies in words, love, and peace that will transform the person despite outward circumstances.
Oppression and the Nature of Evil
The depictions of oppression and evil produce an interesting commentary on how a noble people should endure suffering. On one hand there is the strong critique of Roman oppression through the direct oppression of Barabbas. On the other is a very indirect, even passive, Jesus. Jesus’ revolution is one of the spiritual person, not one of the community’s united resistance, even non-violent resistance.
There are two evils confronted in King of Kings, that of societal injustice and that of personal morality. Barabbas confronts the societal injustice and stands as a figure whose actions are associated with Judas and contrary to the will of God. Jesus, however, faces and defeats an internal evil. When Jesus is in the wilderness being tempted Satan is never depicted. There is a disembodied voice as if to suggest Jesus is not wrestling with personified evil from without, but rather an evil that is within. This is not stated, but implied by the slightly crazed look on Jesus’ face, his obvious thirst, and the use of mirages. Subtly, King of Kings, argues that the most important stand against evil is not the stand against a societal evil, but that of an internal moral struggle.
This seems to stand against the overarching them of the movie and its concern with politics and social activism. It is, however, the individual of exemplarily moral character who first conquers the demons within that truly stands for what is right.
I leave you then with a few questions and considerations. Given that Ray’s King of Kings is centrally concerned with social activism and politics, how does the portrayal of evil fit with this agenda? Should not Jesus be concerned with justice and oppose the Romans openly, even if non-violently? It would seem that one should openly resist this oppression, and indeed modern liberation theology would argue for active resistance against oppression. The majority of liberation theologians would reject violence, but non-violent resistance is a central political activity taken up by these thinkers. Ray’s Jesus is clearly not a Jesus of liberation theology. How then does this Jesus remain a Jesus of justice, love, and extreme moral integrity?