Showing posts with label Passion of the Christ. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Passion of the Christ. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 19, 2011

Two Marys’ of the New Testament as Portrayed in Film: Scriptural Confusion or Cinematic License

The name Mary is the Greek form of the Hebrew name Miriam or Marianne. It can mean wise woman or lady. It was used many times in the New Testament so it was apparently a popular name during that time. The focus of this blog will be on Mary the mother of Jesus and Mary Magdalene. How they are written about in scripture and how they are portrayed in films.
Gospel Scriptural References

The four Gospels (Matthew, Mark, Luke and John) are the main sources of information that the Christian church has on the life or history of Jesus. There are theological disagreements on the historical accuracy of the Gospels since they were written by humans and ascribed as factual wittings of events. There is also debate on whether the ascribed writers were actual disciples or just attributed to these individuals, especially since these were oral stories that had been passed down in the church until they were written down fifty to seventy years after Christ death and resurrection. There is a belief that each of the Gospels where written to different audiences, giving a specific focus to different genres.

Even given all these factors, the Gospels not only mention many women but also give them prominent roles is extraordinary. Especially in a cultural period that women were seen less important than even slaves. Jewish men thanked God daily that they were not born as women. Greek philosophy was admired during that time. The Greek theory of dualism was fluent where everything had an equal and opposite other, negative and positive, women were placed in the negative category.

As the Gospels are our main source for knowledge of the life of Jesus, Christians use this as the litmus test for any other outside portrayal. So we begin our look at these two Marys in the parallel Gospels.

Mary the mother of Jesus

The book of Matthew begins with the birth of Jesus and the importance of Jesus’ mother Mary. Mary is throughout the beginning of the book of the Matthew 1-2. She is the mentioned as Jesus’ mother and Jesus’ other siblings in Matthew 13:55. Matthew then mentions Mary the mother of Jesus at the end of the book were she is present at the crucifixion and resurrection.
In Mark, Mary is mentioned in 6:3 to be Jesus mother and Jesus’ brother and sisters. She is then mentioned in Mark 15-16 at the crucifixion and resurrection. Mark is the shortest of all the Gospels.

In Luke, the book is more comprehensive in the story of Jesus’ life. Luke 1-2 is full of detailed information on Mary and Joseph’s call to be the parents of Jesus the Christ. This is where the connection of Mary and Elizabeth the mother of John the Baptist is told. Mary song is also detailed. The story that Jesus is taken to the temple and how not only Jesus is prophesized over but Mary too. Again, in chapter 24 Mary and women are at the resurrection and told the remaining disciples.

In John, Mary is fist mentioned at a wedding in John 2:1-11 that both she and Jesus attend; where she asks him to turn water into wine. This gives Mary and Jesus’ relations a different dynamic as maybe a center of her family and is respected by her adult son. She is then not mentioned again until John 19 and 20 when she is at the cross with other women and at the resurrection.

Mary Magdalene

Since there are many Marys that are mentioned in the Bible, we will only note the scriptures refer to Mary Magdalene, meaning that she was from the town/village of Magdala on the western side of the Sea of Galilee. This would be done to help narrow what Mary was associated to particular acts.

There are very few references to Mary Magdalene in scriptures. Many times, she is joined with Mary the mother of Jesus and other women. This would seem appropriate since women being alone with a man or men would be inappropriate outside of their family. She is also referred to as a financial supporter of Jesus and his disciples. She may have been looked at as a leader of the group of following women.

In Matthew and Mark, Mary Magdalene is not mentioned until she is at the crucifixion and resurrection of Jesus with other women, Matthew 27:56; Matthew 2761; 28:1; Mark 15:40; 15:47; 16:1, 9.

In Luke 8:1-3 Mary Magdalene is the only time defined as possessed by demons~
After this, Jesus traveled about from one town and village to another, proclaiming the good news of the kingdom of God. The Twelve were with him, and also some women who had been cured of evil spirits and diseases: Mary (called Magdalene) from whom seven demons had come out; Joanna the wife of Cuza, the manager of Herod's household; Susanna; and many others. These women were helping to support them out of their own means.(NRSV)

Again she is indicated as being at the cross and resurrection with the other women, Luke 24:10.
In the book of John Mary Magdalene is referred to by name at the crucifixion in John 19. She then is also at the resurrection and could be considered the first missionary. She meets the risen Jesus and runs to tell the disciples of the resurrected Jesus, John 20:1-18.

Film Representations of Mary the Mother of Jesus and Mary Magdalene

This is where as a Christian if we were presented with only a cinema-graphic picture of these women we may be very confused with the written events in scripture. We do recognize that in writing many things are left out. Even in the Gospel of John 21: 25 he acknowledges this, “But there are also many other things that Jesus did; if every one of them were written down, I suppose that the world itself could not contain the books that would be written.” (NRSV)
So we have to come to viewing films of the life of Jesus as not final authority but recognize it as an entertainment medium. Many times directors and writers will reinvent scenes of characters to fit their own creative view or increase cinematic drama.

Looking at three of the films that we have seen this semester let us see how these Marys have been portrayed.

King of Kings 1927

In this film, a silent film, the portrayal of Mary the Mother of Jesus is seen as virginal and holy. I am not sure that she is not in a scene that does not also have dove flying around. Her dress is very conservative, covered from head to toe. She seems to have a calming presence about her at all times. She is shown in other scenes with Jesus and his disciples that are not present in scriptures. Yet, as a women and the mother of God she is still portrayed in the background, but more holy than others women. She also is represented as having some female camaraderie with Mary Magdalene after her conversion as a follower of Jesus. This Mary has the alluded essences of what many would associate with the Mary of Catholicism.

Mary Magdalene in this film is portrayed so uniquely that I knew I needed to use this film as one of my examples. The film begins with Mary Magdalene as a main figure. She is portrayed as a well to do concubine associated with Judas Iscariot. She is scantily clad, for me surprisingly for this dated film, with heavy makeup and jewelry. She has her own entourage and servants, portrayed as wealthy and a concubine to many famous individuals. She has been given numerous gifts, even a set of zebras she uses for horses. She goes to seek out her wayward suitor Judas who is now following Jesus. She is appalled at being left. When she meets Jesus, she tries to sway him but just his presence affects her so that she begins to change. In a dramatic scene is exercised of seven demons, during which time she is changed. Her hair, clothes and jewels are transformed into a more conservative manner. This is the only movie we watched that actual had the scene of her healing, the only factual reference to her ailment in scripture. Mary Magdalene in now one of Jesus’ troupe and is seen with Mary Jesus’ mother and other women through the film.

Jesus of Montreal 1989

This foreign film is a more modern portrayal of Jesus. It is a little harder to associate who is who in the film because of this. The film is a portrayal of a reenacting of the passion play for a Catholic church. The ‘Jesus’ character, Daniel in the movie, is asked to gather a group of actors to freshen up the old rendition of the play. There is no mother of Jesus in this film but there is a mother figure, who has a young daughter. She portrays this in the friendship of the actors outside of the actual play rendition. This mother is nowhere near perfect as she is having a sexual relationship with the priest in the film. Yet, when the rest of the groups is around, she is the figure that makes sure they eat, is comfortable and is the caring mother character. She also builds a friendship with all the actors and they gather at her home, some evening living there. When the Jesus actor dies, she is there caring for him with the Mary Magdalene character. Even in the end, she is there to encourage carrying on his legacy of truth and justice.

The character that portrays the Mary Magdalene type is Mireille. Mary Magdalene is again portrayed as a sex object. She is an actress that does scantily clad rolls and is sexually involved with her director. The ‘Jesus’ character saves her from this to play in the Passion play. She moves in with the group and the mother figures home. She is called by Jesus (Daniel) to change her way of life and not to compromise herself. There remains a hint that she had some type of attraction to ‘Jesus’ more that platonic but nothing develops in the movie. She becomes friends with the mother character and is there at Jesus’ (Daniel’s) death. Her life as with all the actors or followers of Daniel is change by their experience, not only from the play but also from their friendship.

The Passion of the Christ 2004

As many know this film by Mel Gibson focuses on the last twelve hours of Jesus’ life yet has sprinkled throughout clips of previous events of his life. With Gibson being a Catholic, it is not surprising to see Mary Jesus’ mother as portrayed in a holy perfect light. She seems to be even dressed as a nun throughout the film. She is humble throughout and always in the background with Jesus and his disciples. She is portrayed as a loving mother supporting her son, knowing where his life will lead, to the cross. Yet, there is a wonderful scene of camaraderie with mother and son where he is building a table and she calls him to wash and eat. In the end, she is always there even watching the brutal scenes of his beating, even on hands and knees wiping up his splatter blood. She runs through the street with the disciple John and Mary Magdalene to follow Jesus to the cross. She never leaves his side. They watch his crucifixion, death and burial. The Marys both go to the find to Jesus is risen. She is a devoted mother to the end. One that really cannot compare to anyone human today. No mother I know could mental stand to see such horror happen to their child. This Mary has something more. Some type of superhuman ability to stand this atrocity.

Mary Magdalene is a staunch follower of Jesus and friend to Mary his mother. Here she is portrayed in roles that were not ascribed to her in scripture. An adulterous and the women with the alabaster jar of oil to wash Jesus’ feet. As a follower of Jesus, her clothes and actions become more subdued. She is now a dedicated disciple of Jesus and is seen with His mother throughout his final hours.

Women seem to be more prominent in the film if nothing but as supporters and staunch followers even when many of the disciples deserted Jesus.

Conclusion

Most of the films we have watched have taken cinematic license when portraying many of the scenes in the films compared to the scriptural writings. Yet, it seems that the most dramatic license taken is with the character of Mary Magdalene. She is portrayed as an adulterous woman in almost every film even thought scriptures never say this about her.

As filmgoers, we are to always recognize first and for most, these films are for entertainment value and made for economic profit. If one is seeking personal theological enlightenment, one needs to turn back to the scripture and prayer.

Monday, April 18, 2011

Barabbas: Leader, Rebel, or Murderer?

When looking at the character of Barabbas in Jesus films, it is always interesting to see how he is going to be portrayed and what he will look like. In trying to paint a picture of what Barabbas will look like, one has to wonder what a murderer looks like, how they act, and if they will look guilty or innocent.

Barabbas in scripture
The story of Barabbas can be found in the four gospels: Matthew 27:15-26, Mark 15:6-15, Luke 23:16-25, and John 18:39-40. Matthew uses the word “notorious” to imply that he might have been publicly or generally known. Mark and Luke use the word “insurrection” which could mean that he was arrested with those that took part in a revolt Mark or that he had taken part in the revolt as stated in Luke. John simply says he had taken part in a rebellion. What we know about Barabbas by reading scripture is that he has committed murder and the rest is left to our imagination.

Barabbas in Film
When most films decide to show a scene with Barabbas and Jesus, it seems they usually use the gospel of Matthew to stay true to the biblical text and this is how it usually goes:
Kings of Kings (1961)
This movie shows Barabbas in a way I have never seen him before. It challenges me to ask the question, is Barabbas the King of Kings or is it Jesus. This movie shows us a man that is not only a fighter in the resistance to the Romans but also a leader. The movie opens with 10,000 rebel Jews hiding in the hills and their leader Barabbas is wanted for murder. The Romans had been trying to capture Barabbas but were unsuccessful. The friendship between Judas and Barabbas is also one I find interesting about this movie. It adds an interesting element to think that Barabbas would be “best friends” with the man that would betray Jesus. When Jesus is introduced in the picture, Judas and Barabbas have a conversation about it: Judas: A new prophet has come into town and he has the same first name as yourself, Jesus. Barabbas: we need more fighters and fewer prophets. Barabbas was obviously regarded as someone that was important since they cared enough to tell him a new prophet was in town. It appears Barabbas is still the hero in this movie and he makes the comment: Barabbas: I need a prophet to help me win over the people, can this Jesus do it? Barabbas wanted to meet Jesus but for reasons that had to do with the fight. In this movie, he was known as the Messiah of war and someone that was leading the Jews in their fight for freedom. It was interesting to see how Nicholas Ray had shown us a Barabbas that was young, handsome, and intelligent enough to lead an underground operation to fight the Romans. The scene that shows Pilate asking the Jews who he should release, Jesus or Barabbas happens while Barabbas is in Jail so he never gets to see how the crowd responds or reacts. Upon his relief, he acts surprised that they had actually chosen him but walks away feeling somewhat important. *Movies like The Greatest Story ever Told, Jesus Christ Superstar, and the Last Temptation of Christ do not take the time to show Barabbas at all.
The Passion of the Christ (2004) Unlike Nicholas Ray, Mel Gibson did something different with the character of Barabbas. Barabbas was referred to as a notorious murder, he looked like a villain, and he was very different from Ray’s Barabbas who played the hero. When Barabbas was released to the crowd, they seemed disgusted and did not want anything to do with him. It seemed they feared Barabbas as if his actions were unpredictable. Gibson shows us a man that is slightly over weight, dirty, and blind in one eye (probably lost an eye fighting).


Time and emphasis devoted to Barabbas
The scene with Barabbas can take less than five minutes to go through what happens when Pilate is asking the crowd whether he needs to release Jesus or Barabbas. Some films have taken the time to give Barabbas his five minutes of fame while others have completely ignored that scene. In passion plays, the story of Barabbas does not really say much about the life of Jesus and it would make sense that films don’t really spend too much talking about him. There was a 1961 film about Barabbas which explained what happened to Barabbas after he was released. Since scripture does not say much about his life after his release, one can conclude that such films are based on historical fiction and not fact.


Goals of the filmmaker
When filmmakers like Gibson take the time to introduce Barabbas it seems the goal is to remain true to the biblical text by showing us a notorious murderer. Once in a way you run into directors like Nicholas Ray that embellish the story of Barabbas and make you ask the question, who is the real king of kings.. Jesus or Barabbas? As I said before, the character of Barabbas is not as important as other characters like Judas and when they are not included in passion plays, it is easy to not notice that they have been omitted and when they are included, a director has a decision… whether or not they give Barabbas his five minutes of fame or not even bother mentioning him.

The Many Temptations of Christ: The Temptation of Jesus in Film

The temptation of Jesus, as recorded in Matthew 4, Mark 1, and Luke 4, marks the first activity of Jesus ministry in the Synoptic Gospels. Directly after his baptism, Jesus is driven by the Spirit into the wilderness and is tempted there by the Devil/Satan (depending on translation). This story has been popular material for the film industry and interpretations of Jesus on film. Each Gospel writer and each film director construes this story differently as it begins to shape who Jesus is and what Jesus is about. I would like to suggest that through the many temptations of Jesus as depicted in scripture and film, a variety of Jesuses emerge. The way in which Jesus is tempted and the way in which Jesus responds is integral to the way in which the film identifies Jesus and his mission.
To demonstrate this I will cover three films: The Passion of the Christ (2004), The Gospel According to Saint Matthew (1964), and The King of Kings (1927). I will avoid any in-depth discussion of the Gospel portrayals of Jesus’ temptation because this will take us far from the topic at hand. Suffice it to say that while similar, the accounts are not identical. While the Jesus they present is similarly not identical, their understanding is much more similar than the three films I will discuss here.
The Passion of the Christ
The passion of the Christ follows John’s gospel closely (which has no temptation of Jesus) and is itself a presentation of Jesus’ final hours before the crucifixion; it would seem this is an odd place to begin a discussion on the temptation of Jesus. The film contains not direct scene of Jesus’ temptation as recorded in the synoptics, but there is a highly similar scene in the garden of Gethsemane. This scene is essential a ‘temptation replacement,’ or a dramatic re-imagining of the way Jesus ways tempted throughout his ministry and final hours.
The scene opens with low but ominous music, a downtrodden, suffering Jesus, and a misty creepy feel. Here Jesus is praying in the Gospel fashion to avoid the crucifixion, yet in the end proclaims to fulfill God’s will. In the midst of this prayer a cloaked, androgynous figure interjects questioning Jesus as to whether he believes he can bear the weight of humanity’s sin. Jesus does not directly responds but prays for God’s protection. Satan again interjects saying it is impossible. Jesus again appeals to God, saying it is possible through God’s will. Satan responds by questioning Jesus’ identity. Then a snake slithers from Satan’s feet and as it is about to strike, is crushed by Jesus’ foot and Satan disappears.
This is clearly not a Biblical account but does have multiple attestations in the visions of medieval mystics. So Mel Gibson’s Jesus is more of a Jesus of the medieval mystic than a Jesus of scripture. In this scene Jesus is also seen as carrying humanity’s sin, suffering under the load of sin and what he must do, and in a high stakes battle of identity and mission with Satan. Jesus is here dramatically human in his suffering, yet divine in his will to persist. Mel Gibson’s Jesus is a suffering Jesus, yet triumphant Jesus. A Jesus riveted with pain, yet finally dedicated to the task before him. In moving the temptation of Jesus into the garden is displays Gibson’s focus on the role of Jesus in the divine-human drama of sin and redemption. The temptation of Jesus, while certainly contributing to the identity of Jesus, serves here to reinforce his role as sasvior more than his identity as a person.
The Gospel According To Saint Matthew
Pasolini’s version of the temptation is a much more literal interpretation of the Biblical text. All of the dialogue is directly from the Gospel of Matthew, as is the progression of the scene. Jesus is a first alone and then approached by Satan. The temptations of food, testing God, and power over the world all come one after another. After being told to leave Satan looks sad and shuffles away. Throughout the entire scene Jesus is rather dispassionate and seems very unconcerned at the appearance of Satan. At most Satan was a minor inconvenience of his alone time in the wilderness. There is no hint of Jesus being hungry or in anyway worse for the wear after forty days in the desert.
This presentation is interesting because Pasolini presents a principally human Jesus. Throughout the film Jesus is seen in the grim and struggle of the lower working class. His temptation occurs in the same harsh conditions. Jesus responds with no significant strength or Godly response. Jesus is a human like any other human, simply a strongly moral and unwavering in his convictions. In Pasolini’s presentation of Jesus the viewer is invited to join with Jesus and resist the forces of evil and oppression just as Jesus had. Jesus is primarily a teacher, and his action stand as instruction as well, ‘go and do likewise.’ In this rendition of the temptation of Jesus we are told to resist gratifying our sensuous appetites, lust for power and need to control. Instead, we are to join Jesus in opposition to institutions of power and a recognition that God is with the poor and marginalized.
The King of Kings
The King of Kings has a remarkable portrayal of Jesus’ temptation; there is none. Cecil DeMille presents a passively divine Jesus where there is almost no passion in any of his activities. DeMille’s Jesus is almost completely divine and so there is no temptation, Jesus is beyond temptation. Persons are transfixed and transformed by Jesus’ presence. Of course De Mille does not come out in say this in the film, it is implicitly demonstrated throughout the film.
I Satan had appeared to Jesus one could imagine that he would be immediately changed by Jesus presence. Mary Magdalene, portrayed as licentious and loose, is immediately cleansed of her evil and spurned on to modesty simply by meeting eyes with Jesus. Satan has no chance against De Mille’s Jesus, no temptation is possible for the Son of God.
Conclusion
Three different films have produced three different Jesuses with three different treatments of the temptation. The Passion had a temptation, which displayed more about Jesus’ role as a suffering savior than about him as a person. Pasolini’s Jesus was of a morally upright and unshakable, very human Jesus. DeMille presented an entirely divine Jesus without temptation. Many scenes could be analyzed to determine how Jesus is portrayed, the temptation scene is one of many ways to go about this project. It is inevitable that different interpretations of Jesus would be evidenced by the directors’ approaches to the temptation scene. Who is Jesus in this film? Look at the temptation, or its absence, its bound to give you a clue.

Tuesday, April 12, 2011

The Passion of the Christ (2004, Mel Gibson)



Brief summary of the film

The Passion of the Christ is a 21st Century film which portrays the last twelve hours of Jesus Christ before he was crucified. The movie is in Aramaic and Latin and that definitely gives it a different feel. The movie seems to start in the middle of everything and we join in when Jesus is in the Garden of Gethsemane praying. Interesting enough and unlike other passion plays/movies, Satan appears to Jesus in the Garden and has a conversation with him. Jesus doesn’t really pay Satan too much attention and eventually Satan disappears.


In the beginning of the movie, we don’t see Judas betraying Jesus but we can assume it has already happened because Jesus is arrested and the movie takes a different turn. The Pharisee’s bring Jesus to Pilate so he can decide if he will be saved or condemned to death. The pharisee’s tell Pilate Jesus’ crime and but Pilate responds by handing the matter over to King Herod. Herod (who seems to be hung over or maybe recovering from a night of festivities) laughs at the matter, thinks Jesus is crazy, and has him sent back to Pilate.


Pilate gives the crowd a choice, Barabbas or Jesus – crowd picks Barabbas and Jesus is handed to the Roman solders to be whipped. This happens repeatedly with a strip of leather with spikes on it. He is whipped front and back and viewers watch as the blood oozes out of Jesus’ back and stomach. The solders inflict pain but are careful not to kill him (just yet). They bring him back to Pilate, who literally washes his hands and walks away. Jesus carries his cross and is eventually hung till his death. This movie has a lot of interesting symbols included in the midst of al the violence such as the snake that appeared in the garden while Jesus was praying. I’m not really sure what that was supposed to mean but If Satan had not appeared during that scene I would have thought the snake would have symbolized Satan’s presence in the garden with Jesus. When I see children in Jesus films, I usually think of what Jesus said in Matthew 19:14, Jesus said, "Let the little children come to me, and do not hinder them, for the kingdom of heaven belongs to such as these." In this movie, children are portrayed as little devils and Satan can be seen caring a child while Jesus is being whipped children. The children are also seen tormenting Judas to his death and image can be disturbing. Maybe Mel Gibson wanted us to see that evil can also be found in what looks innocent and If Satan can use a serpent, then why not a child.

Style and era it was made


This film was released in the United States on Ash Wednesday, April 25, 2004. I find it interesting that this movie would premier on a night when millions of people are beginning their forty days of prayer and fasting. Lent gives us time to reflect on the life and suffering of Christ. Some take this time to repent, meditate, and ask what Jesus would do? This movie is not in English but it was filmed in Aramaic and Latin. I believe this was a way for the film to show its authenticity. This film was well received and while Gibson says he made this film for the unbeliever, I believe it has an evangelical feel to it.


Films intentions and emphasis


“My intention for this film was to create a lasting work of art and to stimulate serious thought and reflection among diverse audiences of all backgrounds,” says Gibson. Gibson wanted to stimulate serious thought and reflection and that he did. The movie is rated R for “sequences of graphic violence” and blood is the result of this violence and in my opinion the intention.


"The ancients believed that blood was the seat of the emotions.” Blood is a universal, cultural, biblical, and sacred symbol that has different meanings for a lot of people. From the time Jesus is arrested, this movie shows a lot of blood. I’m not sure what’s worse, the violence or the amount of blood that is spilled. In the bible, blood is sometimes used metaphorically to present sacrifice and suffering. I would say Gibson wanted to use blood to stir up emotions of guilt. I also believe Gibson wanted his audience to think of the blood Jesus shed for the atonement of sins and also have an awareness of having done wrong or committed a crime, accompanied by feelings of shame and regret. Mel Gibson also says “my ultimate hope is that this story’s message of tremendous courage and sacrifice might inspire tolerance, love and forgiveness. We’re definitely in need of those things in today’s world.” I agree with Gibson that we are always in need of tolerance, love, and forgiveness but I don’t think this movie stirred up those feelings nor would I walk away thinking tolerance, love, and forgiveness can only be found in the church or through the suffering of Jesus Christ.


Audience for this movie


Maybe Mel Gibson was incorrect when he said he made this movie for the unbeliever because this film does not offer enough information about the life and teaching of Jesus to get an unbeliever to raise questions about faith and Christianity. This film starts in the middle and for the rest of the movie, we see a man that is tortured and does not have a problem hiding his mental and physical pain.


The perfect audience for this film would be evangelicals, biblical scholars, and church study groups. These audiences will probably have background information about what is going on without raising too many questions about who Jesus really is and why he suffered the way he did. Due to the violence, I would also add this movie is not appropriate for young children or maybe even the elderly. Passion is a word that means the suffering of Christ. Mel Gibson titled this film The Passion of the Christ and that is exactly what we saw, the suffering of Jesus Christ.

Monday, April 11, 2011

Gibson’s The Passion of the Christ? Successful Guilt-Trip or Bad Horror-Movie?

Why did Mel Gibson’s The Passion of the Christ move some to conversion or repentance while leaving others cold? While acknowledging that a plethora of personal, relational and cultural factors contribute to the manner in which any individual receives a movie, this piece contrasts two possible responses. First it considers the response of those who buy into a theology of substitutionary atonement. This group includes most Evangelical Christians and also the “unchurched” who are often familiar with the assumption that “Jesus died for our sins” and have not subjected this position to critical reflection. Second, I consider the reaction of those who have reservations about models of atonement rooted in vicarious blood-letting and either reject or qualify such theologies. This group, I will argue is more likely to experience The Passion as horror movie than as a call to repentance.

There may be a curious sense in which Evangelical Christians and the “unchurched” are both likely to endorse a theology of substitutionary atonement, that is, the view that Jesus died to pay a debt incurred for all humankind by the sin of Adam and Eve. Evangelicals generally reject other models of redemption while the unchurched are often unaware of the theological alternatives. While defending himself against the charge of anti-Semitism, Gibson revealed his thinking on blood atonement. Gibson was asked about the choice to maintain in the script the words from Matthew’s Gospel, "His blood upon us and on our children!" (Mt. 27:25) but not to include this line in the subtitles. Gibson’s response was:

"I wanted it in. My brother said I was wimping out if I didn't include it. But, man, if I included that in there, they'd be coming after me at my house. They'd come to kill me." (The New Yorker, September 7, 2003, Perri Dorset)

On another occasion, Gibson elaborated with regard to this passage:

"It's one little passage, and I believe it, but I don't and never have believed it refers to Jews, and implicates them in any sort of curse. It's directed at all of us, all men who were there, and all that came after. His blood is on us, and that's what Jesus wanted." (Terry Lawson, "Mel Gibson and Other ‘Passion’ Film-makers say the Movie was Guided by Faith", Detroit Free Press, 2004).

Hence Gibson sees his audience as in some sense responsible for the violence on screen. Gibson claimed that the made the movie primarily with the unchurched in mind, a group for whom the guilt-trip might evoke “prodigal” pasts. (Leslie Smith, Living in the World but not of the World Walnut Creek: Alta Mira Press, 2004, p. 47)

To be fair, atonement theology takes many forms including St. Anselm’s theory of substitutionary atonement wherein God is no sadist baying for blood but a rather impotent deity constrained by some cosmic version of the feudal honor code from forgiving the sin of humanity. In contrast, some models of substitutionary atonement in modern fundamentalism purport to know the will of a God who preordained the suffering and death of Jesus. Such views persist in contemporary ultra-conservative Catholicism, for example, in the work of Scott Hahn. The point for this movie is that such theology can lead to the conviction that ones own sins somewhat contributed to one of those lashes, blows, nails, thorns or falls.

The irony is that for the vast majority of viewers, Jesus’ blood sacrifice was, in Gibson’s view, ineffective. Peter J. Boyer's “The Jesus War: Mel Gibson & "The Passion" (9-15-03) identifies a source of major dissension that was swept under the shroud. Boyer writes:

"I told Gibson that I am a Protestant, and asked whether his pre-Vatican II world view disqualified me from eternal salvation. " He paused. 'There is no salvation for those outside the Church,' he said. 'I believe it.' He explained, 'Put it this way. My wife is a saint. She's a much better person than I am. Honestly. She's, like, Episcopalian, Church of England. She prays, she believes in God, she knows Jesus, she believes in that stuff. And it's just not fair if she doesn't make it, she's better than I am. But that is a pronouncement from the chair. I go with it.”

On a related note, whether or not the Passion can fairly be described as anti-Semitic, Gibson’s remarks may indicate the eschatological fate he imagines to lie in store of Jews. Gibson rejects Vatican Two’s Declaration on the Church’s Relation to Non-Christian Religion (Nostra Aetate). Still, presumably Gibson grants salvation for Jews like Miriam of Nazareth a.k.a. Mary the Mother of God, Cephas Son of Zebedee a.k.a. St. Peter, the other apostles and the patriarchs and prophets of the Hebrew Bible. At least, Gibson concedes Resurrection to Jesus –Bar –Joseph from Nazareth.

I posit that the movie may be received very differently by those who either reject or significantly qualify theologies of blood atonement. Such positions include those that locate the savific value of Jesus death in its moral example, those who emphasize the value of Jesus’ life and who see the cross as the culmination of evil, rather than of God’s will, and those who appeal to the Biblical understanding of blood sacrifice as celebratory, reuniting blood (signifying life) with the giver of life. Those who embrace the insights of the thrust of modern biblical scholarship are unlikely to view Jesus’ death as payment for the personal sins of a historical Adam and Eve or for any individual living or deceased. Some might point to the role of systemic/ institutional/ social sin in bringing about the death of Jesus. These and other interpretations of the death of Jesus other than substitutionary atonement are not conducive to a personal guilt-trip. Indeed for viewers so persuaded, the movie may hold more in common with the genre of the horror-movie. By contrast, it could be argued that the Evangelical audience is likely to be less au fait with horror movies and hence less prone to the conditioned stock-responses to which that genre can give rise.

This movie exhibits elements of the two sub-genres of “slasher” movie and supernatural thriller. The movie out-bleeds most slasher movies, arguably numbing the viewer to its effects. A classification of the movie as a supernatural thriller reflects a Satanic presence, manifested in apparently feminine form, arguably impelling the relentless assault on Jesus. Indeed, Jesus’ adversaries, Roman and Jewish behave as though possessed, their apparent delight in unspeakable violence otherwise inexplicable. A legion of demons infests the movie, its presence sometimes ambiguous as to whether an objective manifestation or the subjective nightmare of a character is being conveyed.

It was my initial intention to make the claim that a movie received as a horror-movie must fail to move the religious sensibilities of a media-savy audience. However it may be fairer to say that a bad horror movie cannot move religious sensibilities. This qualification may be appropriate since, in the sub-genre of the supernatural thriller, particularly those concerned with the battle between Christians and oppression by supernatural evil, some powerful movies are to be found. The last bastion of the “hero priest” may be in this subgenre. This is be true to some extent for The Exorcist (1973, William Friedkin) but, even more so, I would argue for The Possession of Emily Rose (2005, Scott Derrickson,) and The Rite (2011, Mikael Håfstrom) both movies claiming some basis in actual cases (as is also the case for The Exorcist) These movies testify to the courage and selflessness of the exorcists who are inspirational, Christ-like figures and fully developed characters with whom the viewer might empathize. Even zombie movies, notably Twenty-Eight Days Later (2002, Danny Boyle) can, albeit rarely, poignantly rehearse the nobleness of self-sacrifice in the face of hopeless adversity. This acknowledgment of the religious possibilities conceivably possible in the genre broadly termed “horror” may be all the more damning for The Passion.

In conclusion, it may be for the following reasons that The Passion fails to move the religious sensibilities of many: (1) Critical thinking kicks in, raising questions about the salvific value of blood-letting so that a visceral reaction is supplanted by an intellectual one. (2) The excessive blood and violence approach the farcical and numbs the sensibilities of the viewer. (3) The lack of character development inhibits identification with a credibly human Jesus. (4) Absent also is the development of an agenda of hatred, making it difficult to comprehend the motives of Jesus’ torturers. Instead we witness mindless brutality by an array of ghouls who seem to have strayed off the set of Dawn of the Dead to which The Passion would yield its box-office position. (5) Any depiction of intelligible human motivation seems to be replaced by an implied supernatural influence. (6) The “slasher” element and the “exorcist” element combine so that some receive the work as a horror movie. With some notable exceptions, the conventions of the horror movie offer a safe distance between viewer and action so that the savy viewer is unlikely to be cut to the core, each time the zombie’s devour another victim. The movie may offer an effective guilt-trip for those who believe their personal sins contributed to the execution of Jesus. On the other hand, for those who relate the events upon which the movie is based to institutional evil and moral complexity, the mise-en-scène is too remote from their concerns to evoke much more than distaste at the spectacle of an hour-long slaughter.